Vygotsky!
Vygotsky!! Vygotsky!!! =
Toronto! Toronto!! Toronto!!!
By
Lem Londos Railsback
In
August, I purchased a Greyhound-International Pass
(a wonderful bargain for less than $400 American)
for 15 days to tour the Mid-West, cross the international
border into Toronto for the Carib Festival and our
N.S.S.A. meeting, visit Niagara Falls, dash across
the western provinces to Vancouver, and return to
Laredo, Texas. Needless to say, I walked funny --
like I was molded into a chair, as one neighbor put
it -- for the first few days after my return. However,
my mind and my spirits are still soaring from the
Toronto experience.
This year's Summer Seminar of the National Social
Science Association in August was wonderful! As always.
I visited with old friends, I made new friends, I
saw new sights, and I learned a great deal. Because
we met in Toronto, for the first time in our history,
we found ourselves surrounded by many different languages,
different foods, different styles of clothing, different
musics, and interesting individuals. After all, Toronto,
the largest city of the entire nation, is an international
financial center, servicing Canada, North America,
and the world. I arrived on the last day of the International
Carib Festival. The music and the dances transported
me immediately into my old days and nights in the
Bay Islands of Honduras. Some of the dances and drum
syncopations that I saw and heard in Toronto were
the same that I had seen in La Ceiba and Coxen's Hole
on Roi Tan Island nearly 20 years ago. I was amazed
to find that festival participants had come from as
far away as Atlanta and New Orleans (probably because
of its proximity to the Bay Islands, New Orleans probably
holds the largest Garifuna population in the United
States), and, likely, various Caribbean sites. Needless
to say, my first day and my first night in Toronto
were spectacular!
The skyline of the city stretches far along the shore
of Lake Ontario. Over time, ancient littoral drift
deposits -- continuously moving sand bars, if you
will -- originated up-river and moved westward to
form a natural harbor between the great Lake Ontario
and the Toronto shoreline. Inside that peninsula lie
several islands, one of which was known by early European
settlers of the area as "Hiawatha's Island."
(I had to wonder if the "Hiawatha" that
we knew in long-ago elementary school might be the
same one that gave the island its name. Researching
this could make for a great theme for an energetic
high school student.)
On one of those double-decked boats that every lucky
American gets to go on at least once in a lifetime,
we went for a dinner cruise in and around the islands.
From friendly local Torontonians seated at the next
table, we learned that a great storm in the mid-1800s
had ripped a large gap from the eastern part of the
peninsula and transformed the former peninsula into
a genuine island, known today as Toronto Island. Over
time, on that island, several wealthy families had
build summer homes, several hotels had been built
at different times, and a baseball stadium had been
constructed. Babe Ruth, according to the locals, hit
his "first professional home run" in that
stadium. As we drifted by the island, I was amazed
by the number of ducks resting in the water. Like
those pictures we see on television of the soaring
birds of an African savannah, the ducks were soaring
into the rays of the setting sun and coming back down
to feed, to visit, and to sleep.
A couple in our party took the elevator trip in the
CN Tower up to the 181st story. The wife got a special
scare when she finally looked down because she had
not realized that the "floor" of the main
Observation Pod was made of a special transparent
glass. For the last quarter of a century, this tower
has enjoyed the distinction of being the "world's
tallest building and free standing structure."
As home to a large entertainment, shopping, and broadcasting
center, the physical tower itself provides an amazing
tour. However, because I was more interested in street
scenes at the moment, I omitted the tour. When I return
one day, I will surely go up the first few floors.
After the Seminar, I left Toronto for Niagara Falls
on the Canadian side, one of the seven natural wonders
of the world. Frankly, I was amazed. I finally understood
a word that many of my students use often. "Awesome!"
That was truly my word for the Falls. I am still amazed
at where all that water must come from! I am simply
amazed and awestruck at that wonderful place.
Both in Toronto and at the Falls, particularly along
the shorelines, the many parks and manicured gardens
trumpeted their colors and their scents. Only through
long and thoughtful care do such plant embroideries
live in all their multicolored splendors! Walking
leisurely through one of these plazas/parks/gardens
provides a feast for the eyes, for the nose, and for
the psyche.
To N.S.S.A., I presented a professional theoretical
construct on Vygotskian learning theories. Lev Semyonovich
Vygodsky (spelled later in the West as "Vygotsky")
was born in 1896 to a middle-class Jewish family in
Russia. Well-educated in private school, he graduated
at the age of 17 and applied to the university. At
that time, only three per cent of the Jewish population
was allowed admittance to the university (eight decades
before the Clinton "rainbow" percentages!).
Eventually accepted, Lev proved to be a very accomplished
student/scholar/original thinker and graduated during
the Revolution. Interested in psychology, philosophy,
art and aesthetics, sociology, psycholinguistics,
and pedagogy, he excelled in all of them. Alexander
Romanovich Luria, an accomplished world-class researcher
in his own right, cited Vygotsky as the greatest genius
he had ever known. Alexev Leontiev, who with Luria
and Vygotsky formed the "troika of Russian psychology,"
called Vygotsky "the Mozart of psychology"
for his versatility in observation, analysis, and
theory-building in all of his interests. Lev was a
contemporary of Lenin, Lenin's wife Krupskaya -- with
whom he worked at the Commissariat for Education,
Ivan Petrovich Pavlov -- whom Vygotsky admired greatly,
Alfred Adler, Sigmund Freud, Kurt Koffka, B. F. Skinner,
Carl Jung, Jean Piaget -- with whom he corresponded
and differed on the role of language in the development
of the mind, and Alfred Binet -- whom Vygotsky chided
for the "static I.Q." (Vygotsky characterized
the then-new "I.Q." construct of the French
Binet and the American Terman as measures of the fruit
already grown rather than the buds and their potential
growth. As a precursor of constructivists like Jerome
Bruner, Noam Chomsky, Howard Gardner, Robert Sternberg,
and Krashen, Vygotsky proposed his socio-cultural
version of "reconstruction." Lev described
the interplay between the societal environment and
its words in the development of the mind of a child.
Lev's dynamic Zone of Proximal Development still inspires
teachers today. The current revolution a la Vygotsky
in today's Russian schools and the emerging professional
consciousness in the West of Vygotsky's contributions
and road maps for our teachers underscore the shared
treasure of Lev's thought and language. However, true
to form, the societal leaders of Lev's day -- the
Stalin thugees -- arrested Lev for his thinking and
for his talking and for his writing -- in short, for
his over-whelming intellectuality. (Sound familiar?
Never happen in this country!) Overworked, frustrated,
and worried, Lev, only 37 years old, died in 1934
before he was to be brought to trial. Two years later,
the national government, wishing to protect the state
from Lev's ideas, banned his books.
Gita L. Vygodskaya observes, "Even though so
many years have passed, Vygotsky's thoughts, ideas,
and works not only belong to history, but they still
interest people. In one of his articles, A. Leontiev
wrote of Vygotsky as a man decades ahead of his time.
Probably that is why that he is for us not a historic
figure but a living contemporary." In the same
vein, Lev and I have been talking and listening since
1958 -- vicariously, of course. And I have been following
his road-maps since that same year, my very first
year of teaching. I have made a few wild turns along
the career way, but only because I myself misread
the road-maps in every single mis-turn. F. Allen Briggs,
my intellectual father and patient mentor since 1955,
first introduced me to Shakespeare, Hayakawa, Skinner,
Pavlov, and Vygotsky, along with a host of other giants.
As I have taught all these years, I have enjoyed the
advantage of being able to turn to my friends Allen
(American), Willy (English), Sammy I. (Canadian),
B. F. (American), Ivan (Russian), and Lev (Russian)
for assistance whenever I needed. Like Gita, Lev's
daughter, I consider them to be my constant companions
and guides for life. For me, they are my contemporaries.
Our friend Lev articulates "wild" ideas
about parents, certain peers, and some professionals
serving as significant others. His "far out"
vision of cooperating students in pursuing relevant
common goals is nearly six decades ahead of American
learning theorists and nearly nine decades ahead of
today's American schools' instructional practices.
Some of our educational provincials -- rural, urban,
suburban -- still don't "get" Lev's recommendations.
Lev's "social reconstruction" notion that
each generation re-creates its own culture and language
dynamically frames the human condition, regardless
of century and regardless of location anywhere in
the world. With his multicultural emphasis, Lev would
feel right at home in 21st century Toronto. Lev's
staunch defense of the freedom of each individual
to create that human's reality mirrors the free interactions
and celebrations of Toronto today. I suspect strongly
that Lev would love to serve today as a teacher-intern
supervisor and mentor in the multilingual, multicultural
Toronto schools and in the neighboring Montreal schools.
After all, the school systems of both metropolitan
centres are Vygotskian miracles-in-progress.
(Lem
Londos Railsback is a professor at Texas A&M International
University's College of Education in the Department
of Curriculum and Instruction.)